What's a wrecked 2009 Subaru Legacy worth?
$175–$400
Priced from 59 US auction sales of 2009 Subaru Legacys in the last 6 months — every condition from lightly damaged to non-running.
Price my Legacy — free estimate + free offersTakes about a minute · adjusts for your damage, mileage and title
The 2009 Subaru Legacy auction market at a glance
The middle half of sales ran from $175 to $400, a 2.3x spread, so the damage on the car matters far more than the badge.
76% still ran and drove when sold; most were lightly or moderately damaged, which props up the median.
The most common primary damage was front end (37% of sales), followed by side (28%).
Next to neighboring years of the Legacy, a 2010 brought $25 more at the median.
The typical one crossed the block with about 147,000 miles.
Where the money lands
A Legacy that runs and drives with a clean title sells near the top of the range; heavy damage, missing parts or no title pulls toward the bottom. Answer six questions and the estimate adjusts to your car.
2009 Legacy auction price trend
Monthly median with the typical (25th–75th percentile) band.
What kind of damage these had
Get your exact number
The range above covers every 2009 Legacy sold — wrecked lightly and totaled completely. Your car's damage, drivability, mileage and title move it thousands of dollars inside (or past) that range. The free estimate takes about a minute; your precise, condition-adjusted number — with recent comparable sales, photos and parting-out economics — is in the full report ($1.99). Real offers from licensed buyers are always free.
Start my free estimateWrecked 2009 Subaru Legacy questions
How much is a wrecked 2009 Subaru Legacy worth?
Most sold for $175 to $400 at US auctions over the last 6 months, with a median of $275 across 59 sales. Where yours lands depends on the damage, whether it runs, mileage and title.
Does it matter if my 2009 Subaru Legacy still runs?
Yes. 76% of the ones sold still ran and drove. Runners with light damage sell toward the top of the range; non-runners, flood and fire cars sell toward the bottom.
Should I part out my wrecked 2009 Subaru Legacy or sell it whole?
At a median of $275, selling whole usually wins: parting out takes months, and fees and the leftover shell eat most of the difference.
Can I sell a 2009 Subaru Legacy with a salvage title?
Yes. Buyers of damaged cars handle salvage titles every day and price the brand in. A missing title narrows the pool of buyers more than a salvage brand does, and state rules decide who can buy a car without one.
Other Subaru Legacy years
2025 Legacy 2024 Legacy 2023 Legacy 2022 Legacy 2021 Legacy 2020 Legacy 2019 Legacy 2018 Legacy 2017 Legacy 2016 Legacy All Legacy years →
More wrecked Subaru values
2015 Forester 2024 Crosstrek 2017 Outback 2014 Forester 2017 Forester 2016 Forester 2019 Crosstrek 2015 Outback All Subaru models →
Figures are aggregate US auction sale results for this year, make and model over the trailing 6 months, rounded to $25. Informational only — not an offer to purchase or an appraisal of any specific vehicle.